A news story reports that people are better able to identify long-standing fictional cultural icons than transient non-fictional government officials. F’rinstance: more people can identify members of the Seven Dwarves than the Supreme Court:
Three quarters of Americans can correctly identify two of Snow White’s seven dwarfs while only a quarter can name two Supreme Court Justices, according to a poll on pop culture released on Monday.
The implication here is that there’s something surprising or tragic about the fact people know more about fictional icons they grew up with than government officials they didn’t elect.
Personally, I don’t buy that. It’s natural for people to know more about things they’ve known their whole lives than transient, recent stuff. Supreme Court Justices serve only for a time, but the Seven Dwarves are forever. Further, the Supremes haven’t hired a PR firm as good as Disney’s to get their images known by every five year old in the country. And–to be honest–I’m not sure that most Supreme Court decisions have as much impact on the average person’s life as a DVD of Snow White.
Okay, sure, I’m disappointed about how few people know the real-world facts behind the poll (which also revealed that more people know that Krypton is Superman’s home planet than know Mercury is the closest planet to the Sun or that more people know who Harry Potter is than who Tony Blair is).
I can be worried about how much ignorance about the world there is, but I’m not worried about the fact that people know the icons of their culture well–particuarly when it’s knowing long-standing icons versus transient political figures.
Oh, and in case there’s any suspicion that this is sour grapes from someone who knew more Dwarves than Justices, here are my lists of both–before reading the story so there was no chance of spoilage on any of their names:
DWARVES:
1. Doc
2. Grumpy
3. Sleepy
4. Sneezy
5. Bashful
6. Happy
7. Dopey
JUSTICES:
1. Roberts
2. Scalia
3. Thomas
4. Alito
5. Kennedy
6. Ginsburgh
7. Breyer
8. Stephens
9. DopeySouter
FEDDIE OVER AT SOUTHERN APPEAL HAS ANOTHER TAKE ON THE DWARVES VS. JUSTICES ISSUE.

